The dilemma of humanitarian intervention muhammad hassan zia assistant professor university of the punjab gujranwala campus gujranwala, pakistan. The rule of law in an incoherent world ian hurd t he concept of humanitarian intervention has evolved as a subset of the laws governing the use of force and has very quickly come to occupy an institutional position alongside selfdefense and security council authorization as a legal and legitimate reason for. How is just war theory related to humanitarian intervention. His discussion of order turns to the subject of law, both domestic and. Such suffering tends to be the result of a government instigating. Additionally, the cnn effect was the driving force behind the u. This is a dissertation about humanitarian intervention, the use of military force across borders to prevent or stop the violation of human rights. In social studies and social policy, intervention theory is the analysis of the decision making. The position of the international court of justice 83 2.
The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice. Jan 22, 2014 neither of these applies to situations of human rights or humanitarian crisis, although in the era of humanitarian intervention the security council has stretched article 42 to provide a justification for intervention, e. A journal of philosophical, theological and applied ethics vol. John rawls, one of the most influential political philosophers of the twentieth century, offers his theory of humanitarian intervention based on the notion of wellordered society. However, without a consensus in the security council this cannot happen.
Itsg forms a, b and c are provided to organize the information called for in these itsg phases. The liberal case for humanitarian intervention by fernando. Humanitarian intervention essay sample sample essays. The concept of humanitarian intervention is controversial because it creates a context in which one country can justify invading another and deposing its leaders. A theorybased approach for developing interventions to change.
In addition to problems regarding the content of the concept of humanitarian intervention, there are also technical problems. This paper will address the tension between state sovereignty and humanitarian intervention. Gary bass, princeton university professor and author of freedom. The development of development theory and practice 3. Humanitarian intervention and nonideal theory oxford. Humanitarian intervention is a postcold war activity. Reviewed by linda melvern published on hgenocide april, 2003 humanitarian intervention and the case of rwanda the limits of humanitarian intervention by. Humanitarian intervention and the reduction of harm. This article examines factors that motivate major powers to participate in humanitarian interventions, with a case study of us intervention in somalia during the period 199293. Syria and the crisis of humanitarian intervention politics. Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention by. Yet it would be a mistake to conclude that, as a textbook, it offers nothing new.
Humanitarianrefers principally to the motives for the intervention, namely, to save foreigners from the ills inflicted upon them by their rulers or by powerful, protected groups in their own country. Michigan journal of international law humanitarian. Intervention for human protection is a key component of english school thinking about the rights and duties that states. This article sets out eight liberal principles that underlie humanitarian intervention, some of them abstract principles of international ethics and others more concrete principles that apply specifically to humanitarian intervention. Humanitarian intervention and international relations. The humansecurity framework is proposed as a basis for setting the objectives of interventions and for guiding empirical research on methods and impact. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and. For more information and the latest updates, please visit the hls coronavirus information page. Humanitarian intervention ethical,legal,andpoliticaldilemmas edited by j. Humanitarian intervention is a practice that needs to be. Interventions based on health behavior theory are not guaranteed to succeed, but they are. Humanitarian intervention in the long nineteenth century book description.
It is adapted from whos mhgap intervention guide 2010, a widelyused evidence. The first theory, which features prominently in grotiuss writings, asserts that natural law authorizes all states to punish violations of the law of nations, irrespective of where or against whom the violations occur, to preserve the integrity of. For walzer, however, the priority is to chide fellow leftists for failing to defend the option of humanitarian intervention in theory, not to understand today why almost nobody thinks it improves the world in practice. Towards a theory of regional responsibility to protect. Conditionalists recognize the legality of humanitarian interventions, but to curb abuse would allow the unilateral use of force for humanitarian purposes when certain objective criteria are met. Planning theory and evidencebased behavior change interventions. Humanitarian interventions are the result of dynamics at both the actor and case level of analysis. This essay begins with definitional discussions of the key terms of any such debate. This paper discusses how international relations theories realism and liberalism can explain states responses to humanitarian crises.
This is an excerpt from system, society and the world. Orford provides critical readings of the narratives that accompanied such interventions and shaped legal justifications for the use of force by the. A history the dilemma of how best to protect human rights is one of the most persistent problems facing the international community today. Humanitarian interventionthe doctrine of humanitarian intervention in international law typically refers to the threat or use of force by a state, group of states, or international organization primarily for the purpose of protecting the nationals of a particular state from widespread deprivations of internationally recognized human rights, including genocide and crimes against humanity. This chapter discusses the implications these two theories have for when, why, and under what conditions, humanitarian intervention is morally permissible, and judges the extent to which each theory employs moral reasoning that treats human wellbeing as the highest moral. This chapter argues that the philosophical debate around humanitarian intervention would be improved if it were less idealtheoretic. A theoretical assessment of humanitarian intervention and r2p. The work contains two interrelated theses, one normative, and one interpretive. Mednicoff university of massachusetts, amherst the contemporary international law of war is torn between the pressure to incorporate a doctrine to legitimize limited armed humanitarian intervention and its traditional concerns for nations sovereignty. What methods may be used in impact evaluations of humanitarian assistance.
The moral basis of humanitarian intervention terry nardin he is the author of law, morality, and the relations of states 1983 and the philosophy of michael oakeshott 2001, as well as editor with chris brown and nicholas rengger of international relations in political thought. A situation could arise in which a government might exaggerate or exploit a humanitarian crisis to justify an otherwise unjustifiable takeover of another country. Could humanitarian intervention be legally justified in extreme cases. The issue of humanitarian intervention has become increasingly prominent in worldwide debates regarding its role in ethics and legitimacy in international relations.
Despite the widespread occurrence of humanitarian emergencies such as epidemics, earthquakes, droughts, floods and violent conflict and despite the significant financial resources devoted to humanitarian assistance, systematic learning from such interventions. International humanitarian aid concepts trends by howard adelman 1. Humanitarian intervention is legitimate when it is directed at suppressing human rights abuses and complies with the doctrine of double effect. Humanitarian intervention, actions undertaken by an organization or organizations usually a state or a coalition of states that are intended to alleviate extensive human suffering within the borders of a sovereign state. Since the 19th century, humanitarian interventions have often been treated as suspect because they may be used as mere vehicles for national aggrandizement, imposition of puppets in power, or for the institution of political and economic systems detested by the indigenous population. Ehealth, apps, framework, theory of change, healthy eating, physical activity, complex. Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention. Humanitarian intervention definition of humanitarian. Such interactions are similar to a natural organism that reacts in response to the changing components of its immediate surroundings as well as its evolutionary response to. Order, for ramsey, must serve justice, which is the higher moral goal. Theoretical assessment of humanitarian intervention and the responsibility to protect. Uncertainty arises as to whether there are any moral obligation for humanitarian intervention and the concerning justifications of the violation of state sovereignty. The dilemma of how best to protect human rights is one of the most persistent problems facing the international community today.
Humanitarian intervention on its face incompatible with article 24 81 2. Hehir walks the reader through the difficult conceptual terrain of humanitarian intervention, locates the subject within just war theory, and illustrates how various theoretical perspectives on international relations approach the topic. It relies on twin assumptions of liberal moral and political theory. Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention criddle.
Such an approach, it is argued, involves empirically scrutinizing two. A uk foreign and commonwealth office note of october 1998, circulated. Humanitarianrefers principally to the motives for the intervention, namely, to save foreigners from the ills inflicted upon. From humanitarian intervention to the responsibility to. During the 1990s, humanitarian intervention seemed to promise a world in which democracy, selfdetermination and human rights would be privileged over national interests or imperial ambitions. The moral basis of humanitarian intervention nardin. This unique and wideranging history of humanitarian intervention examines responses to oppression, persecution, and mass atrocities from the. It argues that whilst these principles do not determine the. As far as they represent political values, interests, and demands that cut across the borders of the states. The overarching goal of the authors was to determine which components of the health belief model. According to rawls, a wellordered society should be peaceful and legitimate, and it must respect basic human rights. Exploring the english school of international relations.
Despite these origins, the term as used generally refers to a broad range of real time modern media, and is not exclusive to cnn or even 24hour news cycle broadcast cable news. Theory of reasoned action and theory of planned behavior. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect, and. This wording also serves to emphasize the fact that the forces engaged in the intervention are bound by humanitarian law in their military operations. Two research hypotheses are recommended for testing. Within the context of behavioural research, interventions have often been based on whole individual theories such as the health belief model 7. One, in target states where humanitarian intervention is being considered, there are two distinct and easily identified groups. The success and failure of humanitarian intervention. Gibbs university of arizona, tucson, arizona, usa abstract. For more information and the latest updates, please visit the hls coronavirus information page tweet this. This article explores three theories of humanitarian intervention that appear in, or are inspired by, the writings of hugo grotius. The origins of the doctrine can be traced to the inception of the modem period and finds its support in. Because humanitarian intervention involves at least a degree of compulsion of a state with regards to events within its sovereign territory, it can at least in theory be distinguished from wider humanitarian action or 7 rosenau, intervention as a scientific concept, 1526. The just war theory and its implementations date back to the greeks and the roman empire.
Abstract the aim of this paper is to define humanitarian intervention, to analyze its purpose and to evaluate its value in international law. May 07, 20 the history and politics of humanitarian intervention some are calling on president barack obama to intervene in syrias civil war. Humanitarian intervention is generally understood to be the transboundary use of military force in order to halt or avert largescale and grave human suffering, and is a subject that has attracted much scholarly attention in recent decades. Humanitarian intervention under existing international law 80 2. Nongovernmental organizations ngos are increasing the influence they are able to play on global politics. The liberal case for humanitarian intervention by fernando r. Humanitarian intervention, the responsibility to protect. The second edition is available now on amazon uk, usa, in all good book stores, and via a free pdf download. To these ends, the intervening forces may undertake a variety of peace operations aimed at creating security and suppressing conflict. The morality of intervention in international theory. The objective of the legal analysis in this paper is to determine whether the legal and legitimate basis for humanitarian intervention exists under international law and if so, when and under whose authority. The humanitarian system is made up of several componentsactors, norms, and practicesthat collectively contribute to shaping policies and interventions for people in need.
Harvard university and harvard law school will shift to remote teaching and learning beginning monday, march 23. Natos humanitarian war over kosovo columbia university. One theory asserts that natural law authorizes all states to punish violations of the law of nations, irrespective of where or against whom the violations occur, to preserve the integrity of international law. Select bibliography works in russian are to be found in the notes of chapters 6 and 9. Interventions are increasingly described as theory based. Other questions and problems concerning humanitarian intervention. Humanitarian intervention in the long nineteenth century. Humanitarian intervention is a use of military force to address extraordinary suffering of people, such as genocide or similar, largescale violation of basic of human rights, where peoples suffering results from their own governments actions or failures to act. The validation of humanitarian intervention and its capability, are addressed in this essay taking into account the current humanitarian crisis in the world. List of books and articles about humanitarian intervention. Advancing behavioral science requires a good understanding of how interventions are.
Hbm and the theory of planned behavior tpb were most. At its heart is the alleged tension between the principle of state sovereignty, and the evolving norms related to individual human rights. Describing the causal pathways linking the intervention and the health. The dilemma of humanitarian intervention council on foreign. Ngos roles in humanitarian interventions and peace support operations. The theory and practice of humanitarian intervention and. Humanitarian intervention remains a very controversial area of international law. A comprehensive presentation of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice during the course of the nineteenth century. Pdf ngos roles in humanitarian interventions and peace. Three grotian theories of humanitarian intervention by evan j. The theory permits states to resort to war in two principal cases.
Armed humanitarian intervention internet encyclopedia of. Inthreeshort months,asmanyas1milliontutsiswereshot,burned,starved,tortured, stabbed,orhackedtodeath. The mhgap humanitarian intervention guide is a simple, practical tool that aims to support general health facilities in areas affected by humanitarian emergencies in assessing and managing mental, neurological and substance use conditions. This dissertation examines whether the academic literature on humanitarian intervention is likely to contribute to its objective of establishing a viable mechanism for protecting victims of largescale internal violence by means of military intervention. The history and politics of humanitarian intervention. What stage do violations have to reach for there to be an intervention.
The evolution away from the discourse of humanitarian intervention, which had been so divisive, and toward the embrace of the new concept of the responsibility to protect has been a fascinating piece of intellectual history in its own right. This unique and wideranging history of humanitarian intervention examines responses to oppression, persecution and mass atrocities from the emergence of the international state system and international law in the late sixteenth century, to the end of the. This book is a comprehensive presentation of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice during the course of the nineteenth century. Abstract when is humanitarian intervention legitimate and how should such interventions be conducted. The history of humanitarian intervention in theory and practice seminar 2nd term 20142015 organized by dirk moses hec and jennifer welsh sps mondays 11. Where do we find, and how do we integrate this information. The legal status of humanitarian intervention and its relationship to international humanitarian law humanitarian intervention is a jus ad bellumquestion.
The issue of humanitarian intervention has generated one of the most heated debates in international relations over the past decade, for both theorists and practitioners. Using theory of change to develop an intervention theory for. The paper makes the liberal argument for intervening by force to end or prevent serious human rights abuses. Humanitarian intervention and the auecowas intervention treaties under international law. Texts from the ancient greeks to the first world war 2002. This theory is an aid to sdaapp design and evaluation and it can be used to consider the question of the. Global support for the responsibility to protect doctrine weakened after the unendorsed nofly zone that helped topple libyas regime, and debate. State practice evidence of the humanitarian intervention.
163 1595 1591 559 403 942 911 398 1103 1422 46 417 767 1036 872 1267 84 494 1055 1172 687 80 257 466 694 78 114 122 369 771 1361 860 1468